BestHeaters is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more

Top 11 Best Pool Heater From The Customers’ Reviews In 2022

John Miller
  Dec 9, 2022 5:07 AM

We have tested several references from different experts to provide you with the final reviews about top-ranking products. In this article, you will get an insight into the pool heater’s definition, all types of pool heaters, suggestions before the purchase, and the frequently asked questions about pool heater use. 

With all of the useful information that we supply you below, hope that you can find the best pool heater. 


Compare Products

Showing  1 - 10  in  11 results
TOP Choice
1
  • SCORE
    9.6
    BH Score

    With the use of a unique algorithm called BH Score, our specialists at bestheaters.org are able to evaluate products based on consumer feedback, price trends, and current market movements. We use the BH score for scoring. It automatically calculates the scores from 0 to 10 depending on the data gathered. BH Score is not influenced by any manufacturers or sales agent websites.

  • Brand
    SunHeater
TOP Choice
2
  • SCORE
    9.4
    BH Score

    With the use of a unique algorithm called BH Score, our specialists at bestheaters.org are able to evaluate products based on consumer feedback, price trends, and current market movements. We use the BH score for scoring. It automatically calculates the scores from 0 to 10 depending on the data gathered. BH Score is not influenced by any manufacturers or sales agent websites.

  • Brand
    SunHeater
TOP Choice
3
  • SCORE
    9.2
    BH Score

    With the use of a unique algorithm called BH Score, our specialists at bestheaters.org are able to evaluate products based on consumer feedback, price trends, and current market movements. We use the BH score for scoring. It automatically calculates the scores from 0 to 10 depending on the data gathered. BH Score is not influenced by any manufacturers or sales agent websites.

  • Brand
    SmartPool
4
  • SCORE
    9.0
    BH Score

    With the use of a unique algorithm called BH Score, our specialists at bestheaters.org are able to evaluate products based on consumer feedback, price trends, and current market movements. We use the BH score for scoring. It automatically calculates the scores from 0 to 10 depending on the data gathered. BH Score is not influenced by any manufacturers or sales agent websites.

  • Brand
    Stiebel Eltron
5
  • SCORE
    9.0
    BH Score

    With the use of a unique algorithm called BH Score, our specialists at bestheaters.org are able to evaluate products based on consumer feedback, price trends, and current market movements. We use the BH score for scoring. It automatically calculates the scores from 0 to 10 depending on the data gathered. BH Score is not influenced by any manufacturers or sales agent websites.

  • Brand
    Ecosmart US
6
  • SCORE
    8.8
    BH Score

    With the use of a unique algorithm called BH Score, our specialists at bestheaters.org are able to evaluate products based on consumer feedback, price trends, and current market movements. We use the BH score for scoring. It automatically calculates the scores from 0 to 10 depending on the data gathered. BH Score is not influenced by any manufacturers or sales agent websites.

  • Brand
    Hayward
7
  • SCORE
    8.6
    BH Score

    With the use of a unique algorithm called BH Score, our specialists at bestheaters.org are able to evaluate products based on consumer feedback, price trends, and current market movements. We use the BH score for scoring. It automatically calculates the scores from 0 to 10 depending on the data gathered. BH Score is not influenced by any manufacturers or sales agent websites.

  • Brand
    Raypak
8
  • SCORE
    8.6
    BH Score

    With the use of a unique algorithm called BH Score, our specialists at bestheaters.org are able to evaluate products based on consumer feedback, price trends, and current market movements. We use the BH score for scoring. It automatically calculates the scores from 0 to 10 depending on the data gathered. BH Score is not influenced by any manufacturers or sales agent websites.

  • Brand
    Raypak
9
  • SCORE
    8.6
    BH Score

    With the use of a unique algorithm called BH Score, our specialists at bestheaters.org are able to evaluate products based on consumer feedback, price trends, and current market movements. We use the BH score for scoring. It automatically calculates the scores from 0 to 10 depending on the data gathered. BH Score is not influenced by any manufacturers or sales agent websites.

  • Brand
    Hayward
10
  • SCORE
    8.6
    BH Score

    With the use of a unique algorithm called BH Score, our specialists at bestheaters.org are able to evaluate products based on consumer feedback, price trends, and current market movements. We use the BH score for scoring. It automatically calculates the scores from 0 to 10 depending on the data gathered. BH Score is not influenced by any manufacturers or sales agent websites.

  • Brand
    SunQuest

Last update on 2022-12-09 / Affiliate links / Images, Product Titles, and Product Highlights from Amazon Product Advertising API


What Is A Pool Heater And How Does It Work?

A pool heater, sometimes called a water heater, is a type of heater that transfers the taken water from the pool to the tank and returns heated water into the pool. Applying the same method with the convection heater but the heater takes water as an input and output as well.

A unique side of heaters in each category of heater has a discrepancy in main features and running motivations.


The Pool Heaters’ Categories

There are three main different types of pool heaters on the current market which are solar pool heaters, electric heat pumps, and gas pool heaters. Each of them has its own key features but all of these models can work perfectly with many common strengths such as durability, economical budget, or energy efficiency.

Solar Pool Heater

A solar pool heater harnesses the sun’s rays and utilizes solar panels to increase the temperature. As the temperature rises, the solar panels will absorb the heat and energy from the sun and convert it into the water circulation process.

One of the most environmentally-friendly, long-term usage, enables your swim season to linger for several weeks. However, because of the complicated installation required to assemble the model, users will have to pay a long manual effort in setting up a completed solar pool heater.

 A normal solar pool heater may take you three days to accomplish the installation while the ground model mounted on the roof often requires you a long time to finish as well as a large effort in reinforcement.

Read more: Best Solar Pool Heater

Electrical Heat Pump

The electric heat pump takes the heat from the atmosphere and uses an outer evaporator air coil to transfer the heat circulation. This model is highly evaluated for energy efficiency as well as saving money. Compared to traditional heaters using natural gas, the electric heat pump brings to customers a durable product with high longevity (may last for 10 to 20 years) and high sustainability.

Moreover, the model is renowned for great performance at an affordable price which is around $50 to $100. Another big plus of this model is simple installation and usage. The air temperature is recommended to be at least 55 degrees Fahrenheit.

Gas Pool Heater

The final one in this classification is named the gas pool heater. As its name suggests, the model runs on natural gas or propane consumption.

The dominant advantage of this heater is the reasonable price, in the range of $1,500 to $6,000, which is lower than the two options above.

Like the price, you just need to pay $300 to $500 per month for each gas pool heater. The heater still gives off the heat with efficiency at high speed.

Nevertheless, this gas heater cannot be maintained for as long as the solar or electric model. The heat emission produced by natural gas can also cause air pollution. keep in mind that the gas pool model does not depend on sunlight so any changes in climate will not affect the device’s operation result.

Customers also view: Best Gas Pool Heater: In-Depth Advice & Key Factors


Some Pieces Of Advice To Heed Before Buying A Pool Heater

There are a couple of things you need to know before purchasing a pool heater, especially for newbies. As we mentioned before, a pool heater varies well from this type to this type and each one operates in a different method.

Before reading this section, we recommend that you should brainstorm the idea about the frequency you use the heater and the highest temperature that you want to get and write them down on a piece of paper. If you finish, let’s start.

Categories Of Pool Heaters

There are three core categories of pool heaters, which are determined by the energy source that the heater uses.

Natural Gas

If you need the heater to heat up water rapidly, you may choose heaters using natural gas. Natural gas helps your pool heat your pool in just a few hours while solar or electrical heaters may cost you a day or two days to warm up the water.

Electricity

However, the electrical model also has its own strength that is running in a long-term session. An electric pool heater works in the same way as the heat pump for your home does. This heating process allows the electric heater to run stably throughout the early spring and late fall months.

You might also like this: Best Electric Pool Heater: How I Choose & Test One

Solar

Solar heating is an optimal choice for homeowners like environmentally-friendly products with a low budget. The solar heating method in pool heating is regarded as a much less involved approach. Rather than spending money monthly or daily on the fuel source, solar heating harnesses the radiant heat from the sun to warm the thermal panels.

Nevertheless, this type of model is limited more in winter because the sun in the winter is less than in other seasons.


Pool Heater’s Price On The Market

On average, modern pool heaters range between $1,782 and $4, 011 with a national average of $2,860. You also need to heed the factors which can affect your maintenance cost. They are respectively:

Heating Unit Type

Heating an electrical product will cost you less running costs in some areas but in other areas.

Labor

With a large outdoor pool heater, you cannot handle the setup by yourself. That’s why you need to hire specialists to help you install it. Following HomeAdvisor, the typical labor fee for installing a pool heater is between $50 and $1,500.

Location And Climate

The amount of sun can affect not only the type of heater you choose but also the cost. That’s why you need to consider carefully your climate status in your living address before choosing which kind of heater you should use.

Pool Size

Another determinative factor that can increase your budget on the heater is your pool’s acreage. Pool pros estimate that a pool heater has to generate 50,000 BTUs of heat for every 5-00 and 1-000 gallons of water.

The higher the BTU of your unit is, the faster the pool will meet the desired temperature. In cool weather, you must double the BTU to get the expected heat in the same period of time.


Top Prestigious Reviews: What Are People Saying About These Products?

1. SunHeater S1204 Universal Solar Pool Heater 2 by 20-Feet

 SunHeater S120U Universal Solar Pool Heater 2 by 20-Feet, Black

Customer Ratings:

  • 3.6 out of 5 stars 

The Unique Functions:

  • Item model number: S120U
  • Item Weight: 18 pounds
  • Manufacturer: SPQ Brands 
  • Patented web design for optimal exposure to sunshine 
  • Pool water can raise 6-10 degrees F

2. SunHeater Solar Heater S2220AG for Aboveground Swimming Pools

SunHeater Solar Heater, Includes Two 2’ x 20’ Panels (80 sq. ft.), 10-Year Warranty – Heating System for Aboveground Swimming Pools – Raises Water...

Buy from Amazon

Customer Ratings:

  • 4.0 out of 5 stars 

The Unique Functions:

  • Item model number: S2220AG 
  • Item Weight: 27 pounds
  • Manufacturer: SPQ Brands 
  • Water temperature raises 15 degrees F
  • Extends Pool Season 
  • The filtration system comes with the necessary plumbing fixtures 
  • The tube-on-web design captures the maximum sun’s rays

3. Smart Pool S601 for Inground Pool Solar Heating System

Smart Pool S601 Inground Pool Solar Heating System, Includes Two 2’ x 20’ Panels (80 sq. ft.) – Made of Durable Polypropylene, Raises Temperature Up to 15°F...

Buy from Amazon

Customer Ratings:

  • 4.2 out of 5 stars 

The Unique Functions:

  • Item model number: S601 
  • Item Weight: 29 pounds 
  • Manufacturer: Esse Sales Inc 
  • A polypropylene heat collector 
  • Direct Flow System - One Header Hole for Each Heating Tube 
  • Square Footage: 80 square feet 
  • Pool Water raises between 6 and 10 degrees F

4. Stiebel Eltron Tankless Water Heater

 Stiebel Eltron Tankless Water Heater - Tempra 29 Trend – Electric, On Demand Hot Water, Eco, White

Buy from Amazon

Customer Ratings:

  • 4,5 out of 5 stars 

The Unique Functions:

Part Number: 239217 

  • Item Weight: 24 pounds
  • Capacity: 0.39 Gallons  
  • Manufacturer: Stiebel Eltron 
  • Installation Method: Mounting 
  • The small and sleek white design saves spaces 
  • Auto modulation 
  • One electronic switch 
  • Temperature Output: 68 degrees F and 140 degrees F
  • 7-Year Leakage and 3-year Parts Warranties 

5. Ecosmart US SMART POOL 27 Electric Tankless Pool Heater

 EcoSmart SMART POOL 27 Electric Tankless Pool Heater, 27kW, 240 Volt, 112.5 Amps with Self Mo...

Buy from Amazon

Customer Ratings:

  • 3 out of 5 stars 

The Unique Functions:

  • Item Model Number; Smart POOL 27
  • Item Weight: 24.2 pounds
  • Manufacturer: Ecosmart Water Heaters 
  • Certification: CSA/ ET/ UL
  • Flow Activation
  • Compact and easy-to-install design 
  • Eco Smart Remote Control 
  • Wattage: 27000.0 
  • 2-year warranty

FAQs

What Size Of Heat Pump Or Gas Heater Do I Need For My Pool?

As a rule, high-quality pool heating always uses a sizing calculator to determine the accurate size for your swimming pool. If you are not concerned about paying money to get the most professional calculator as well as analysis for your pool size, just call the customer service of the brand you buy the heat or any external calculating service available.

Should I Use A Solar Cover For The Solar Pool Heater?

For the time being, many homeowners think that a solar blanket or a solar cover is an unnecessary tool with some inconvenience. This point of view expresses a lack of knowledge about this useful accessory.

Solar can save you about fifty percent of your monthly bill. The input of water and chemical substances needed to add regularly can be reduced as well.

How Do I Get Warranty Service As Buying Pool Heaters?

Luckily, in the product review section of this article, we have provided you with the warranty information. If you order items or appliances on the Amazon site, there will be consistency between almost all introduction pages about merchandise that is the product specification. The warranty information is usually set at the end of the table.

There still exist some products that are not shown the warranty information on the reviews page. If this situation happens, you just need to call the hotline of the manufacturer. They will send employees to your house to introduce you to the warranty. But if the producer doesn't have a service center in the local area, they can hire a heating and cooling contractor to make the repairs.

Can I Service My Pool Heater?

Yes, you can. A licensed technician always conducts an annual service. If you want to get the most quality and professional assistance from the customer service group, you can contact the Pool Heating System to subscribe to this right.

Since you subscribe to the service, office staff will contact you each year when servicing is due.

Do I Need A Separate Pump For The Pool Heater?

The answer is no. A heater can turn on and off the same plumbing as your pool pump. However, you will need to possess a Priority to Heat controller. This controller plays a role in announcing when to turn it on. This method will help the users remain at the heater's desired temperature.

Recommended Reading:


5
2 ratings